In a previous article for The Gospel Herald (“The Unique Value of Humans in the Age of AI“), we explored the unique value of humans in an increasingly AI-dominated world. This article delves deeper, examining how our understanding of self-worth can be falsely intertwined with our work and how the rise of AI challenges this notion.
The “What I Do” Identity
Many of us define ourselves by our careers. Our jobs, and the income they generate, often dictate our social standing, our sense of purpose, and even our self-worth. This is understandable. Work provides structure, and a tangible contribution to society. However, this “what I do” identity can become especially problematic when we consider the power of AI Tools.
A common belief in Canada, often rooted in a secular worldview, is that true fulfillment comes from having a unique and high-paying job – “following and finding your dream”. This creates immense pressure to achieve both ‘career success’ and ‘personal fulfillment’, often at the expense of other important aspects of life.
However, a Christian perspective suggests that we can find joy in work that many others do, regardless of whether it’s high-paying or even paid at all.
AI Feedback Loops emphasize the ‘artificial’ in ‘artificial intelligence’
As we discussed in the previous article, AI Tools can be very useful, simplifying more and more complex tasks everyday.
However, AI researchers have observed a concerning phenomenon: AI systems can fall into “feedback loops” where they begin to mimic and amplify their own outputs. Unless humans provide review and their own feedback, this can lead to distorted and inaccurate outputs.
This “looping” highlights a crucial limitation of AI: it can only ever be a reflection of existing data, often flawed and incomplete. Human ingenuity, with its capacity for critical thinking, original ideas, and nuanced understanding, (at this time) remains essential to filter, refine, and correct the biases and inaccuracies that inevitably arise from AI systems. We need to become “gatekeepers,” diligently identifying and correcting “AI ghosts” – the phantom echoes of flawed information that permeate AI-generated outputs.
Genesis and the Meaning of Work
The book of Genesis presents a nuanced view of work. While work is an integral part of our human experience (Genesis 2:15), it is not the sole determinant of our worth. God, in creating humanity, intended for us to participate in His creative act – to “work [the Garden of Eden] and take care of it.” (Genesis 2:15 NIV). Banishment from Eden did not abolish work but rather made it more challenging (Genesis 3:17-19).
However, Eden was not merely about work; it was also about relationship – a harmonious communion with God and with creation. This underscores that our value transcends our productivity. We are created in God’s image (Genesis 1:27), reflecting His creativity, compassion, and capacity for relationship.
Human Work in the Age of AI
In an age of increasing automation, it’s crucial to remember that human work remains vital.
- Work as a Reflection of Our Humanity: Work, at its core, is an expression of our unique human qualities – creativity, problem-solving, empathy, and the ability to forge meaningful connections.
- Guarding Against AI’s Limitations: As AI systems become more sophisticated, the need for human oversight will continue. We must diligently scrutinize AI outputs, ensuring accuracy and ethical considerations.
- Honouring Our Image-Bearing: True human flourishing lies not in mere productivity but in reflecting the image of God – as creators, as caretakers, and as beings in loving relationship with others and with God Himself.
Reflecting on the value of Work Beyond Productivity
AI can already perform many tasks that humans traditionally spend their time on, including those that generate income. This begs the question: what is the true value of human work in a world where AI can do so much?
Consider this: “If AI can create an eye-catching image, why do I still find it satisfying to paint one myself?” This question highlights a deeper truth: human value extends far beyond mere functionality. The joy of creation, the struggle for mastery, and the satisfaction of expressing our unique voice – these are experiences whose value transcend simple fabrication.
Similarly, consider this: “If I only had a few hours, and the choice between enriching the lives of the children from my home church or training an AI, where would I best spend my time?” I believe most people, and especially Christians, would agree that spending time with children would be the best use of time. This illustrates that the inherent value of a vulnerable person, regardless of their ability to contribute to society in a traditional sense, underscores the fundamental truth that human worth is not conditional on productivity or economic output.
Reflecting on these questions helps us understand the true value of human identity – as image bearers of God and in our relationships with one another.
The Future of Human Work
The rise of AI does not present a threat to human existence, but an opportunity for us to reconsider our relationship with work, with ourselves, and with God.
It’s crucial to recognize that in some cases, the use of AI may need to be denied if it interferes with the value and place for humans within God’s creation.
However, AI Technology, when used wisely, can augment our capabilities, freeing us from mundane tasks and allowing us to focus on more meaningful pursuits – creativity, innovation, and acts of compassion.
We should not view ourselves as becoming obsolete due to technological advancements. Instead, we have the opportunity to utilize these tools to develop our unique human qualities and gain a deeper appreciation of the unique pursuits and relationships available to us within the realm of creation.
Note: This article was written with the help of Google Gemini for grammar and clarity.
Toronto ON